Showing posts with label advice. Show all posts
Showing posts with label advice. Show all posts

Thursday, May 25, 2017

Sheikh Ahmad Deedat (Zakir Naik’s teacher) on the subject of Shia/Sunni

A lecture given in Iran on March 3, 1982 .
“When it comes to the Shafei, Hanbali, Hanafi and Maliki we are tolerant but when it comes to the Shia you see he is not in the formula that we are taught as a child, so what ever little idiosyncrasies there exists between us and them we cant tolerate and reject we say that he is out because we are programmed to believe in only the four. But we accept the idiosyncrasies between the four. I say why can’t you accept the Shia brothers as a fifth madhab. And the astonishing thing is that he is telling you that he wants to be one with you. He is not talking about being Shia. He is shouting “there is no Sunni nor Shia there is one thing, Islam.” But we say to them “no you are different you are Shia.” This attitude is a sickness of the devil. He wants to divide us. Can you imagine we Sunnis are 90% of the Muslim world and the ten percent who are Shias want to be partners and brothers with you in faith and the 90% are terrified? I cant understand why should you the 90% be so terrified. They should be the ones terrified. “
Another clipping from Sheikh Deedat’s speech
” If a Sunni brother somewhere does something wrong you say oh the individual is not being very Islamic, he is a kaffir, But if a Shia does something wrong you want to condemn the whole Shia community, the whole nation of millions, and say they are all rubbish just because one Shias actions are not very Islamic. At the same time where we look the other way if one of your relatives does something serious because he is your father or your uncle. One group of Sunnis says to another “you are not a Muslim” another group of Sunnis says “you are not a Muslim you are a kaffir” look that’s among us, and we fight among ourselves. And some of us do funny things.”
Sheikh Ahemad Deedat about Shia Using a Clay (sajdagah) to perform Sajood In Salat (Namaz)
“Another example is that the Shia brothers when they make salat, they have a piece of clay (turbah) that they do sajjdah on. And people say “They are worshipping a piece of clay. “ I say why don’t you ask them why they place their foreheads on a piece of clay and learn the logic behind this. You see, the first time I experienced this was in Washington D.C., the Iranian students there had invited me to give a lecture there at the university where they were studying in America. At that time, it was time for Isha and we made salat. And everyone was given a piece of clay. I at the time thought it was so funny, so I put it aside and I made my salat with the Iranian students. And after salat I wanted to know about this and I asked them. Why do you carry this clay tablet everywhere you go in your pocket. They said ” we are supposed to do sujood on Allah’s earth with our foreheads touching the earth. We say “subhanna rabia Allah” three times with our foreheads touching the earth.” So the Shia want to actually touch the earth with their foreheads and not a manmade carpet. They want to be true to the expression of praying with the forehead actually touching Allah’s earth. You see they don’t worship the clay tablet as many wrongly think. And this is always something that we Sunnis are always making fun of and mock the Shia.
Sheikh Deedat about Ayatollah Ruhallah Khomeni
We went to visit the Imam, Ayatollah Ruhollah Musawi Khomeini. There were about forty of us who waited for the Imam and the Imam came in and was about ten meters away from where I was, and I saw the Imam. He delivered the Lecture to us for about half an hour, and it was nothing but the Quran, the man is like a computerized Quran. And the electric effect he had on everybody, his charisma, was amazing . You just look at the man and tears come down your cheek. You just look at him and you get tears. I never saw a more handsome old man in my life, no picture, no video, no TV could do justice to this man, the handsomest old man I ever saw in my life was this man.
Sheikh Ahmed Deedat About Iran
Let me say something about Iran. What I found was that everything is islamically oriented. The whole nation is geared towards Islam. And they are talking about nothing but the Quran. I have never had a single experience with an Iranian when the man contradicted me when I’m talking about the Quran. Whereas our Arab brethren again and again you quote them the Quran and they try to contradict you with the Quran. They are Arabs, they are supposed to know the Quran better than us, but the Iranians seem to be on the wavelength of the Quran. Everything he is doing everything he is thinking about is the Quran.
They are not afraid to say “marg bar amrika” death to America. Then say “marg bar shuravi ” death to USSR. Imagine that! (laughter from the audience). And death to Israel.” Can you imagine a nation doing that and not in the least afraid. This is not the Islamic spirit that is in us here, but the Iranians are all heart and mind. They don’t say “this is an Iranian revolution “or “we are Iranians”. They are talking about Islam, an Islamic Revolution. This is not an Iranian revolution but that this is an Islamic revolution. It’s a revolution for Islam and little wonder why the nations of the world cant stomach it because it is Islam that they cant stomach.
click on the link below to read Sheikh’s complete Speech(worth reading it)

Dr. Israr Ahmed on the subject of Shia Sunni Unity

(17 Mar 1995 Jummah Khutba, Jama Masjid Darul Islam, Jinnah Bagh Lahore)
“If we won’t get serious on this issue now and if we couldn’t achieve shia sunni unity here in this country then God forbid our country Pakistan will break in to pieces, then it won’t belong to shia or sunni. Many people have hopes in this country. This country Pakistan is a result of a half century of struggles of the Muslims of the subcontinent. We got this ced # ountry after a million sacrifices.”
 Surah Aale Imran Ayat #64 Translation
Say (O Muhammad ): “O people of the Scripture (Jews and Christians): Come to a word that is just between us and you, that we worship none but Allah, and that we associate no partners with Him, and that none of us shall take others as lords besides Allah. Then, if they turn away, say: “Bear witness that we are Muslims.”
Dr. Israr Ahmed’s words regarding above Ayat
“Just Imagine Allah (swt) in the holy Quran is talking about the unity between muslims, jews and christans. It is not only possible to be united with other religions (Ale Kitab) but in fact Allah is ordering us to be united with them, so why can’t we muslims be united after all we believe in ONE God and the prophecy of Muhammad (p.b.u.h). This Ayat shows Quran’s Direction and what Quran Wants us to Provoke”
Dr. Israr Ahmed Presented 3 Main Goals To be Achieve Through this Unity
If we achieve Shia Sunni unity then,
  1. We can cut off one arm of terrorism in Pakistan.
  2. The path to achieve the enforcement of Islam in Pakistan can be even and it will be really easy to struggle for it.
  3. The Muslim block can become integrated and united in this region.
Dr. Israr Ahmed Never applied Takfir On Ahl-e-Tashaee Sect of Islam Infact He apposed it always, below is a translation of a Paraghraph from his Book
“I am not convinced to apply Takfir on Ahl-e-Tashaee sect of Islam, and never in my past I tried to impose takfir on them in fact I consider them a sect of muslims. That’s the only reason that irrespective of all my admiration for the leader of Sipahe Sahaba Pakistan (SSP) Molana Haq Nawaz Jhangvi and his honesty I never agree on his standpoint about applying takfir on Ahl-e-tashaee.  Therefore I never agreed or support his standpoint. After his death I was invited to attend a condolence seminar as a speaker but I refuse to go by saying clearly that,”when I never in his life agreed on his standpoint (against shia) so I would not like to give a speech in this seminar just to sparkle my politics.”

Above is another clipping from a book written by a great sunni scholar Dr. Israr Ahmed on the topic of “Need And Importance of Shia Sunni Unity”. I have posted few more clippings of his speeches in this book (with translations) below. This complete book is also available on the internet and its worth reading.  The link for this book is given below
Dr. Israr Ahemd praising the verdict of Sheikh Mehmud Shaltut Of Jamiat-ul-Azhar. Below is a clipping with translation from one of  the books By Dr. Israr Ahmed


Shaykh Mahmud Shaltut’s Fatwa about Shia Madhab(1959) is a symbol of hope

Sheikh Shaltut is remembered for encouraging harmonious interactions between the two branches of Islam: Sunni and Shi’i. He maintained close relations with prominent Shi’i figures such as Seyyed Hossein Borujerdi and zealously campaigned for open discussion and cooperation between the two branches. Shaltut desperately wanted to overcome misconstructions and avoid quarrels between the two sects.
Shaykh Shaltut’s  fatwa about shia Madhab(1959) is still seen as a symbol of hope for those aspiring for a reconciliation between the two branches. Sheikh Shaltut strove to portray Islam to the world as a religion of unity, flexibility, and moderation.
Imam Shaltut send this letter in the year 1959 to a Shia Scholar in response of a query regarding Shia and Sunni Maslak. The Sheikh was Asked if Islam prohibits following the shia School of thouoght? He replied throught a verdict in his letter.
  • One thing in Imam Shaltut’s letter is that, his exellancy addressed the shia scholar as “Dear Muslim” therefore the very first words are showing that Takfir does not apply on Shia Madhab.
  • The second clause in this letter clearly stats that,
“The Ja’fary school of thought which is also known as Al shia Al Imamia Athna Asharee is a school of thought which is religiously correct to follow as other Sunni Schools of thought.
Below is the verdict(Fatwa) of the Head of Al Azhar University, with the original seal.


Unity of Ummah by Qazi Hussain Ahmed

“Unity among Muslims is the need of time and the requirement of the Shariat too. Islam has ordered its followers to be united and to stay away from being scattered…
Source: http://jang.com.pk/jang/oct2014-daily/27-10-2014/col9.htm


200 Muslim Scholars Endorsed The Amman Message(2005) “Shias are Muslim”

‘True Islam and its Role in Modern Society’27-29 I Jumada 1426 H./4-6 July 2005 C.E.  

Statement issued by the International Islamic Conference held in Amman, the Hashemite Kingdom of Jordan.
“1) Whosoever is an adherent of one of the four Sunni Schools of Jurisprudence (Hanafi, Maliki, Shafi‘i and Hanbali), the Ja‘fari (Shi‘i) School of Jurisprudence, the Zaydi School of Jurisprudence, the Ibadi School of Jurisprudence, or the Thahiri School of Jurisprudence is a Muslim. Declaring that person an apostate is impossible. Verily his (or her) blood, honour, and property are sacrosanct. Moreover, in accordance with what appeared in the fatwa of the Honourable and Respectable Shaykh al-Azhar, it is not possible to declare whosoever subscribes to the Ash‘ari creed or whoever practices true Sufism an apostate. Likewise, it is not possible to declare whosoever subscribes to true Salafi thought an apostate. Equally, it is not possible to declare as apostates any group of Muslims who believes in Allah the Mighty and Sublime and His Messenger (may Peace and Blessings be upon him) and the pillars of faith, and respects the pillars of Islam and does not deny any necessary article of religion. “
THIS WAS AMMAN MESSAGE’S FIRST STATEMENT WHICH PROVEs THAT SHIA’S ARE MUSLIM. ALL MUSLIM SECTS ACCEPT THEM AS MUSLIMS NOT APOSTATES AND THE FATWA OF TAKFEER DO NOT APPLY ON SHIA SECT OF ISLAM.
THERE WERE TOTAL 5 STATEMENTS IN THIS CONFERENCE ENDORSED BY ALL SECTS OF ISLAM;
Here are the links to the official website to Amman Message and The Embassy of jordan, so that you can read all of its 5 statements.

Syed Ali Khamenei’s Fatwa for Unity

Leader of the Islamic Revolution Ayatollah Sayyed Ali Khamenei recently issued a religious decree condemning any insult to Sunni Muslims dignitaries. The leader’s fatwa, issued on Oct. 3, was highly welcomed by the Muslim world and drew the attention of the most prestigious religious centers, including Cairo’s Al-Azhar University.

Here is a news published on a Muslim News Website on 2nd , 3rd of October 2010. This website is backed by The Union Of Islamic World Students
Unity Between Shia and Sunni on Syed Ali Khamenei’s Fatwa
Ayatollah Khamenei: Insulting Sunni Dignitaries Unlawful
Leader of the Islamic Revolution Ayatollah Seyyed Ali Khamenei recently issued a religious decree condemning any insult to Sunni Muslims dignitaries. The leader’s fatwa, issued on Oct. 3, was highly welcomed by the Muslim world and drew the attention of the most prestigious religious centers, including Cairo’s Al-Azhar University.
“Desecrating the religious dignitaries of Sunni brothers, including accusations to the wife of Prophet Muhammad (PBUH), is haram (unlawful),” Ayatollah Khamenei was quoted as saying by Taghrib News Agency (TNA). The remarks made by Iran’s leader came in response to a question posed by Saudi clerics regarding a fatwa released by Kuwaiti Shiite cleric, Sheikh Yasser Al-Habib, considered offensive to Ayesha (RA). In a disciplinary measure, the Kuwaiti Cabinet announced its opposition to the sacrilege and annulled Habib’s citizenship.
Chancellor of al-Azhar University of Islamic sciences welcomed Fatwa (verdict) issued by the World Shia Leader, Imam Sayyed Ali Khamenei, which bans any insult to the companions of Hazrat Muhammad (S.A.) as well as his wives
Such insults have always been a source of controversy and dispute between Shia and Sunni Muslims and barred them from forging a robust unity against their common enemies, unlike a multitude of commonalities between the two sects.
Ahmad al-Tayyib wrote in a statement that the fatwa was prudent and timely and would help ram the door shut to seditions.

“I received the blessed Fatwa with appreciation,” he wrote.
He said it was incumbent on all Muslims to try to keep inter Muslim unity and no dispute between different Islamic sects should be allowed to harm the unity of Islamic ummah.
Tayyib also noted that Egypt has ever been at the forefront of every initiative for Muslim unity.
Western media have kept mum on the Fatwa.

Source: Rohama

 ” They have no options, their last effort is the shia sunni issue

then try to say the Islamic Republic (of Iran) is a Shia Republic and try to portray it against the great Sunni society(nations) and try to stir up sectarian tensions and bigotry This is an important and dangerous point, the are in fact doing! (corrupt) political hands are at work All of us must do our utmost, and put all our energy in destroying this plot of the opressive powers everybody must be alert! including all our nation, officials, religious students our hard working religious scholars who serve the people all must pay attention not to do or say anything that will help the plan of the enemies (of Islam) This obligation is also on the Sunni school of thought our Sunni brothers should also know the enemy’s plot is to stir up conflict and sectarianism (between us) to make brothers kill each other! nothing less than this! they too (Sunnis) must be awake and alert to this threat. ”

SHIA SUNNI UNITY

Can I see my Muslim brothers, sisters and children dying in the name of religion, being killed by their own Muslim brothers and I keep silent?
Can I sleep peacefully during the night while my fellow Muslims and their families sleep in fear?
My children wait for me me when I enter home, but in some parts the children receive the dead bodies of their fathers, their mothers, and then there is never ending wait for them in this world, living with the memories of the days when their parents would come back home….. they never come back
We are so weak when it comes to progress and prosperity but so strong when we have to fight with each other?
We confirm our place in Jannah by declaring other kafirs and even killing them as if the Jannah was our sole property and we built it
We hear our religious leaders, but do not listen to our inner soul as humans,  do not list to our Lord, out beloved Prophet(peace be upon him)
We hate dogs, we reason they are najis in our religion, because they attack each other, hurt and kill, the only animal that does this, and then we act like dogs, aren’t we ourselves are najis then? can something which is najis enter paradise
Shia Or Sunni, Who is kaffir, Who is Muslim, Whos is going to Heaven, Who is going to hell???
Unity? what unity? we will not unite with ‘other’ until and unless they become ‘us’
The world moves one, but we cannot, we have to first decide who is right, who is muslim and who is kafir, Shias or Sunnis, doesn’t matter it would mean our destruction by means of collateral damage
We debated this for 1400 years, our previous generations could not resolve this, it brought us to our dark age,
The pain is unbearable, hopes are fading, future is bleak, but I cannot remain silent, I have to speak, I have to tell everyone, I have to do my job, one day I will leave, one day I have to stand in front of my Lord, I will then open my heart, You will also be there, you have to open your heart, if you don’t speak your body parts will, be ready, be prepared what they will say, and imagine would you like that or hate,
My Lord,
You asked me ““The believers are but a single Brotherhood. So make peace and reconciliation between your two contending brothers, and observe your duty to God, that you may receive mercy.” (49:10-11)
I standup, I speak, only for your sake, make my voice heard, may my efforts are accepted,

Message to Sectarian/blind follower

An ultimate message by Reeha Ansari sister


WAllahi that z a real msg of islam
Islam z a msg of peace na not of hatered
Kamal ki bat kahy junaid bhai ne
Allah talah jazaye khyr dye en ko en k darjat ko buland kary r jo deen k lye kam keya enhn ne usy sadqa e jareya banaye ameen
Hamary sath basic prob hi ye h
Pehly bat tu ye k ham deen ki taraf aty hi ni
R agar a b jayn tu ye firqa vareyat khatam ni hoty Hamary
Han Me manty hn k kuch batyn waky hi aqal k khelaf hn galat hn I accept
Lakin zaruri tu ni k har bat pe kufar shirk Ka fatwa lagaya jaye
Second person ki kya neyat
Kya pata....dilun ka malik Allah h wo janta sab
Bt esy behave karna...apny sect ko permote karny k lye
Wohi bat na
Umaty banue na k dauebandy, barelwi wat ever
Just speechless in frount of all these misconceptions
Hamary samny science ka koi hypothesis laye jaye tu us ki verification k lye har point ce sochty
Apny aqal istamal karty k ye theek h ya ni
Lakin deen k mamly mn aqal ce andhy hn ham
Jo molvi hazrat r ye ulma beth k fatwa dye dyn
Us ki blind following ham pe farz
Ab kahan jata hamara intellectual
HashAllahi
May Allah protect this ummah frm misconceptions
Frm hatered
Make us able to spread peace , harmony, pleasure
Islam to h hi msg of peace
Kahan ce ye sab a jata es mn beyound the sences h
Ohhh

Thursday, October 8, 2015

Some Characteristics To Recognise In A Magician – Shaykh Waheed Abdus-Salaam Baalee

Some Characteristics To Recognise In A Magician

Shaykh Waheed Abdus-Salaam Baalee

Compiled & Translated

Abu Hibbaan and Abu Khuzaimah Ansaari


If the characteristics mentioned below are recognised in a person who attempts to heal someone, and if he possesses them then one should be certain that such a person is a magician.

  1. The magician asks the name of the ill person and the name of the mother.

  2. The magician requests some form of clothes of the ill person for example, shirt, hat or handkerchief.

  3. Sometimes the magician requests an animal that he sacrifices without reciting “Bismillah (Begining in the name of Allaah).” then he rubs the blood of the animal on the person’s body and he throws the rest on uninhabited land.

  4. The magician writes spells and talismans (ta’weez).

  5. The magician recites the spells and talisman that cannot be understood by normal people.

  6. The magician gives the patient a veil that has boxes and the boxes contain numbers or letters.

  7. The magician orders the patient to seclude himself from the people for a specific period and to lock himself in a room where sunlight cannot reach him.

  8. The magician sometimes asks the patient not to touch water for a specific period which is normally forty (40) days. And this sign is clear evidence that the Jinn the magician uses are Christian.

  9. The magician gives the patient some things that he needs to bury in the ground.

  10. He gives the patient some papers that he needs to burn and inhale the smoke from the burning paper.

  11. He may chant or murmur in a tongue or language that nobody understands.

  12. The magician sometimes tells the patient his name, the name of his city and the reason for his visit, all as soon as he sees him.

  13. The magician gives the patient a piece of paper or a plate with some letters inscribed on it, and the patient has to mix it with water and drink it.

If you see a single sign from these signs in a person and you become certain he is a magician then do not go to him otherwise the statement of the Messenger of Allaah (sal-Allaahu ‘alayhe wa sallam) will apply to you:

“Whoever visited a fortune teller and believed in what was said to him then he has disbelieved in the religion revealed to Muhammad (sal-Allaahu ‘alayhe wa sallam).” [This hadeeth with its supports is Hasan, and Bazzaar, Ahmad and Haakim have narrated it. See also Saheeh al-Jaami (no.5939)]


Sunday, October 4, 2015

Can weak/Daeef Ahadeeth be used as proof in Islam?

In this article inshaAllah we will throw light on whether Daeef narrations can be used as proof or not and Some objections raised by the people that justify using weak ahadeeth. This is taken from the works of Shaikh Zubair Ali Zai and its translated by brother Raza Hassan with some useful additions at the end. May Allah reward him abundantly for his efforts, Ameen.



Da’eef Narration: In the principles of Hadith, A Da’eef narration is a form of “Non-Acceptable” and “Mardood (Rejected)” hadith. For example; See, Tayseer Mustalah al-Hadith (Pg 62)


There are some people who say that it is totally permissible to act upon a Da'eef hadith, with regards to Fadhaail-e-A'maal, which is not correct according to the Jumhoor of scholars.

In Ahkaam and Creed (Aqeedah), a Da’eef Hadith is rejected according to all the scholars, but some Scholars declare a Da’eef Hadith to be acceptable to act upon in Fadhaail (vrtues), while accepting it to be Da’eef But they limit it to some conditions:


First Condition:It should not be very weak; it should not be the narration of Liars, Fabricators, and those who make very big mistakes.[There is a consesus on this condition.]

Second Condition: It should be in accordance to the general evidence.

Third Condition: When acting upon it one should not believe that the action is well-founded or proven. [See: Al-Qaul al-Badee Fi Fadhal al-Salat Alal Habeeb al-Shafee’ Pg 258]

Fourth Condition: The one acting upon it should believe that this Hadith is Da’eef. [Tabiyeen al-Ajab bima warad fi Fadhail rajab by Ibn Hajr, Pg 72]

Fifth Condition: It should mention a good deed for which there is a basis in sharee’ah.

Sixth Condition: This Da’eef Hadith should not be regarding the explanation of a Sahih hadith.[See: Hukam al-Amal bil Hadith Al-Da’eef fi Fadhaail al-A’maal by Abu al-Yasar Ashraf bin Sa’eed Al-Misri (pg 55)]


To act upon these conditions, It is necessary to do the research on its chain, and the Takhreej of Hadith, when the research is done, and the above conditions are fulfilled, only then a Da’eef hadith will be taken.



The second group of scholars is not in favor of acting upon weak ahadith whether they are in Aqaaid-o-Ahkaam, or Fadhaail-o-Manaqib, and the research of this group is correct and closer to the truth. Because this is proven from the Quraan, Ahadeeth, and the Jumhoor of Scholars. Imaam Muslim, in the muqaddimah of his book, has given several proves for the invalidity of Da'eef ahadeeth in Fadhaail. Whereas the other view، of making the exception of Weak ahadeeth in Fadhaail, is not supported by any verse of the Quraan or any Saying of the Prophet.


The following are the proofs of this group who reject the Da'eef ahadeeth in Fadhaail as well as Ahkaam:



Proof from the Quran:

There are doubts in a weak hadeeth being proven. Meaning we do not know for sure that this hadeeth is proven from the Prophet (peace be upon him) or not, And Allah The Exalted has said:

"And follow not that of which you have no knowledge. Verily! The hearing, and the sight, and the heart, of each of those one will be questioned (by Allah)." [Al-Isra: 36]




Proof from the hadeeth:

The Messenger of Allah (peace be upon him) said: "What is lawful is evident and what is unlawful is evident, and in between them are the things doubtful which many people do not know. So he who guards against doubtful things keeps his religion and honour blameless, and he who indulges in doubtful things indulges in fact in unlawful things, just as a shepherd who pastures his animals round a preserve will soon pasture them in it." [Saheeh Muslim: Bk 10, H. 3882]


Since, a Da'eef hadeeth has doubt in it, therefore, according to this hadeeth, the one who acts upon it ends up acting upon Haraam things. So we should follow this hadeeth and leave the doubtful things aside.



Proof from Sahaba (RA) and Scholars:


From the athaar of the well respected scholars from this group, here comes there references, from which it gets proven that these scholars did not take evidence from Da’eef ahadith.


1.      It is narrated from the Companion of the Prophet (peace be upon him), Abdullah bin Abbaas (radiallah anhu) that he would not agree to even listen to the Mursal narrations.[See: Muqaddimah Muslim H. 21, & Al-Nakat ala Kitaab Ibn as-Salaah: 2/553]

This means that Abdullah bin Abbas (radiallah anhu) did not use to accept the Mursal narrations, even if they were in Fadhaail.


2.       Imam Muslim once said (the summary of which is): A Da’eef hadith is not acceptable in any condition, whether it is regarding Ahkaam, or Targheeb-o-Tarheeb (Fadhaail etc). [Ref: Mudaddimah Sahih Muslim Vol 1, Pg 185, 186 with the Sharh of al-Nawawi 127_ 123/1]


3.       Hafidh Ibn Rajab al-Hanbali said: The meaning of what Imam Muslim has said in the Muqaddimah of his book is that even in the ahadith of Targheeb-o-Tarheeb (Fadhaail), the ahadith should be narrated from those narrators who narrate the narrations of Ahkaam (meaning Trutworthy narrators). [Sharh Illal al-Tirmidhi Vol 1, Pf 74]


4.       Imam Sa’d bin Ibraheem said: “Only the Siqqah narrators should narrate a Hadith from the Prophet (peace be upon him).” [Muqaddimah Sahih Muslim published by Darul-Salam: 31]

From this saying we come to know that Imam Sa’d bin Ibraheem did not used to take evidence form the Weak, and non-trustable narrators.


5.       Abu Bakr ibn al-‘Arabi said that it is not permissible to act on the basis of a weak hadeeth at all, whether with regard to virtuous deeds or otherwise… See Tadreeb al-Raawi, 1/252.


6.       Abu Ishaaq Ibraheem bin Eesa al-Talqani once narrated a Munqati’ hadith of Fadhaail to Imam Abdullah bin al-Mubarak, and he rejected it while criticizing it. [See: Muqaddimah Sahih Muslim Pg 11]


7.       Ibn Lahi’ah narrated a hadith that Prophet (peace be upon him) said: “Whoever sleeps after ‘Asr and loses his mind, let him blame no one but himself.”

Marwaan bin Muhammad al-Tatri (Siqqah) said: I saw in Ramadan that, Imam Layth bin Sa’d went to sleep after ‘Asr, so I asked him: "O Abul Haarith! Why do you sleep after ‘Asr? while Ibn Lahi’ah has narrated to us from the sanad of Aqeel, from Makhool, that the prophet (peace be upon him) said:“Whoever sleeps after ‘Asr and loses his mind, let him blame no one but himself.”

Imam Layth replied: Whatever is beneficial for me, I cannot leave it for the narration of Ibn Lahi’ah from Aqeel. [Al-Kaamil by Ibn Adi Vol 4, Pg 1463]

So we came to know that, Even Imam Layth bin Sa’d did not use to take evidence from Da’eef hadith even if it was the issue of Fadhaail.


8.       Imam Yahya bin Sa’eed used to consider the Mursal ahadith of Imam Zuhri and Qatadah to be nothing, by saying: “Huwa bi manzilah ar-reeh” They are like the air. [Al-Maraseel by Ibn Abi Haatim Pg 3]

This means that even Imam Yahya bin Sa’eed did not use to take evidence from Weak ahadith.


9.       Imam Yahya bin Ma’een said: The Mursal narrations of Zuhri are nothing.[Al-Maraseel by Ibn Abi Haatim Pg 3]

So even Imam Yahya bin Ma’een did not consider da’eef ahadith as Hujjah.


10.       Imam Ibn Hibban said: One who mentions a Da’eef hadith, and a narration which does not even exist, both are equal in ruling. (meaning the existence or non-existence of a Da'eef hadith is equal) [Kitab al-Majroheen 328/1]


11.   Imam Abu Haatim Ar-Raazi and Imam Abu Zur’ah Ar-Raazi once had a discussion on the issue of raising hands in Witr. Imam Abu Haatim mentioned a Hadith, so Imam Abu Zur’ah criticized the narrator Layth bin Abi Saleem present in this hadith. Imam Abu Haatim mentioned a second Hadith, so Imam Abu Zur’ah criticized the narrator Ibn Lahi’ah of this narration, Abu Haatim mentioned a third narration, so Abu Zur’ah criticized the narrator “Awf” in it, later when Imam Abu Haatim asked Abu Zur’ah for the daleel of not-raising the hands, so he mentioned the (Sahih) hadith of Anas that the prophet (peace be upon him) did not use to raise his hands in any dua except the dua of Istisqaa, after hearing this reply, Abu Haatim got speechless. [See: Taarikh Baghdad Vol 2, Pg 76]


We come to know that Imam Abu Zur’ah did not use to take evidence from Da’eef ahadith even in Fadhaail.


12.   Similarly, Imam Shu’bah also used to reject all the Da’eef ahadith. [See: Tahdheeb al-Kamaal]

13. Imaam Ibn Hazm says in 'al-Milal', "and it is not permissible with us that we say as these ahaadeeth say (i.e. those weak and fabricated narrations), or to trust in them, or to take anything from them."

14. Imaam ibn Taymiyyah says, 'and it is not permissible to rely in the Sharee'ah upon da'eef ahaadeeth which are not saheeh or hasan.

15.   The great Scholar of the present century, Shaikh Ahmed Muhammad Shaakir (rahimahullah), who was a great and famous scholar of Hadith, said:

According to me, it is obligatory, in all conditions, to describe the weakness of a weak hadith, because not mentioning its weakness can cause the other person to think that this Hadith is Sahih, especially when the person saying it is from the Scholars of Hadith, whose sayings are to be trusted upon. And that there is no difference in taking a Da’eef hadith in Ahkaam and Fadhaail, In fact there is no evidence for anyone to accept any other hadith from the prophet (peace be upon him), except those which are proven as Sahih or Hasan.[Sharh Alfiyah al-Suyooti Pg 84]


16.   Shaikh Naasir ud-Deen Albani (rahimahullah) said:

"From East to the West of the world, we advice all our Muslims brothers to leave the Da’eef ahadith totally, and turn towards the Sahih and proven ahadith of the Prophet (peace be upon him), because it contains the regardlessness from Da’eef narrations, and it has the riddance of any lie on our Prophet (peacebe upon him)" [Muqaddimah Sahih al-Jaami Vol 1, Pg 56]


For more details, please read the book, "Hukm al-Amal bil-Hadith Al-Da'eef fi Fadhaail A'maal" by Abu Yasar Ashraf bin Sa'eed al-Misri, also read the article of Shaikhul Islaam Ibn Taymiyyah, which he has written on this issue, it is present in his book, "Fataawa Shaikhul Islaam (65/18)"


The saheeh proven reports from the Prophet (peace and blessings of Allaah be upon him) offer us sufficient evidence that we have no need to act on the basis of weak hadeeths.

The Muslim must strive to find out which ahaadeeth are sound (saheeh) and which are weak (da’eef), and be content to act on the basis of the sound reports.






                                                       Answers to the Objections



First Objection:

  • One of our Brothers (May Allah preserve him and guide him), said to me that a Da'eef hadith is acceptable in Fadhaail, because the Scholars/Muhadditheen did not completely reject them, but they took evidence from them in the issues of Fadhaail.

This is his evidence for accepting the weak ahadith.


Answer:


The reason why Muhadditheen have narrated weak ahadith in their books, is not because they used them in the issues of Fadhaail, rather it is not proven from any of them to do that. If you don't agree, then let me also tell the reader that those Muhadditheen who mentioned these da'eef ahadith in their books, among them there are also many Da'eef ahadith which are related to Ahkaam and Creed, so would you say that Muhadditheen did not reject those ahadith also which are related to ahkaam, so they are also permissible to act upon? Obviously not!

This proves that they did not collect ahadith to follow them in Fadhaail, but there is some other reason.

The correct reason why Muhadditheen have collected Da'eef ahadith is given below:

Most of the scholars, while collecting the ahadeeth they did not care about the authenticity, they would first collect all the possible ahadith, and then later do research on it, and put rulings on each hadith.

Hafidh Ibn Hajrsaid: "When the scholars used to mention the ahadith with their Chains (of narrators), they used to think that they now have relieved them from the obligation of narrating ahadith. wallahu a'lam". [ref: Lisaan al-Mizaan Vol 3, Pg 75]

From this we come to know that, besides Sahih Bukhari, Sahih Muslim, and Muwatta Imam Malik, other books contain Weak and Mawdoo' ahadith after narrating which, the scholars have relieved them from their responsibility.

They did not narrate these weak hadiths, to take evidence from them, or to follow them, they only narrated them for the sake of narrating or to free themselves from the obligation.

Many Scholars also wrote the weak ahadith, so that they could warn the people about them and refrain from them afterwards.


For Example:

Imam Abul Waleed said: "Once, when Imam Ahmed bin Hanbal and Yahya bin Ma'een went to Abdur-Razzaq bin Hammam in Yemen to gain knowledge from him, one day Imam Ahmed saw Yahya bin Ma'een writing fabricated ahadith.

Imam Ahmedsaid: "You know that these ahadith are fabricated then why are you writing them??"

Ibn Ma'een said: I know that these ahadith are fabricated, but I am only writing them so that, if tomorrow someone comes and joins them with authentic chains, I would be able to tell him that, "you are narrating a lie, because it is narrated with this weak or fabricated chain.".


Similarly,

Imam Sufyan Thawri said: "I write the ahadith for three purposes,and one of them is to know about the weak narrators (so that he may refrain from them after-wards, or warn the people about them)." [Ref: Al-Ta'deel wal Tajreeh 390/1]

Imam Awzaa'i said: "Just like you learn about the practicable actions, you should also learn about the non-practicable actions." [Ref: Al-Ta'deel wal Tajreeh 390/1]



From all the above sayings of Muhadditheen, we came to know that Scholars did not preserve the Weak ahadith becuase they wanted to follow them in Fadhaail, but they preserved them for other reasons which are mentioned above.

 More references can be read in this article inshaAllah:



Second Objection:

Imaam Ahmed considered it permissible to act upon a weak hadeeth.Imam Ahmed bin Hanbal said: "When it is narrated to us pertaining to Halaal wal Haraam we are strict. And when it is narrated to us pertaining to Fadaa'il al-A'maal (the rewards and excellence of actions) then we are lenient." [Al-Kifayah by al-Khateeb: Pg 134]

Answer:


Firstly: This saying is not proven from Imaam Ahmed with an authentic chain. The chain of this saying of Imaam Ahmed is severely weak due to the narrator, Abul Abbas Ahmed bin Muhammad as-Sijzi, and Abu Abdullah al-Naufli. [See: Lisaan al-Mizaan: 1/253, 252 & 1/167]

The summary is that this saying is not proven from Imaam Ahmed bin Hanbal that he used to act lenient with regards to the ahadeeth of Fadhaail al-A'maal.


Secondly:

al-Allaamah Ahmad Shaakir says,'and as for what Imaam Ahmad bin Hanbal and Abdurrahmaan bin Mahdi, and Abdullaah bin al-Mubaarak said, "when it is narrated to us pertaining to Halaal wal Haraam we are strict. And when it is narrated to us pertaining to Fadaa'il al-A'maal (the rewards and excellence of actions) then we are lenient." -then they mean, according to what I find to be most convincing - and Allaah knows best - that the leniency was in their taking the hasan hadeeth, that which does not reach the level of saheeh. Because the convention of distinguishing between the Saheeh and Hasan was not present at their time...rather many of the early scholars did not describe a hadeeth except by it being saheeh or da'eef only.' ['al-Baa'ith al-Hatheeth' (pg.101) of Ahmad Shaakir.]


So what is clear is that the term hasan was not present at that time, and a great deal of what these scholars used to narrate in terms of fadaa'il was of the level of what the later scholars called hasan.

So the opinion from the above mentioned scholars is to leave acting by the weak hadeeth in totality, except where there is a consensus of the Islamic scholars on the issue at hand, and Allaah knows best. And as for the claims of some that Imaam Ahmad amongst others of the early scholars allowed weak ahaadeeth to be used in Sharee'ah rulings then that has no firm basis as mentioned above.

And especially in this day and age, when so many innovations and misunderstandings about Religion are present, many of them having their roots in these da'eef ahaadeeth, it becomes even more essential to narrate only authentic ahaadeeth as part of the process of purifying the understanding of the Religion.

Imaam ibn Taymiyyah says, 'and Ahmad bin Hanbal or others like him from the Imaams did not rely upon this type of ahaadeeth in the Sharee'ah. And the one who relates from Ahmad that he used to rely upon the weak ahaadeeth, which are not saheeh or hasan, has erred.'

So the narrations from him that he would act upon a da'eef hadeeth when there was nothing else present in the texts on that subject, or nothing that contradicted that da'eef hadeeth, does not mean that Imaam Ahmad used them as proof in the Sharee'ah. Allaah knows best. [al-Qaa'idah al-Jaleelah' (pg.82) of ibn Taymiyyah]




Third Objection:

The same Brother, in order to prove the permissibility of acting on weak ahadith, gave an evidence by saying that:

 
Imaam Bukhaari compiled the greatest collection of sahih hadith which is known as Sahih Bukhari. But he also compiled a number of other books in which he included WEAK hadith, such as in Adab al-Mufrad. Imam Bukhari was aware those hadith were weak but he still included them in those books, because they were not intended for fiqh and rulings rather they were intended for adab and encouraging fadhail. End Quote

Answer:


The Brother in his comment, somehow, without knowing, has already answered his objection himself.

If it was permissible according to Imam Bukhari (rahimahullah) to narrate and practice weak ahadith in Fadhaail,then why didn't he do it in his Sahih Bukhari?? Why he only included Sahih ahadith in his book? He did not narrate a single Da'eef hadith of Fadhaail in his book!! This is a proof that Imam Bukhari did not used to take evidence from Da'eef ahadith in Fadhaail.

Now remains the question, Why Imam Bukhari narrated weak ahadith in Adab al-Mufrad??so the answer is that, he didn't narrate those weak ahadith in Adab al-Mufrad to follow them in Fadhaail, rather he narrated those weak ahadith in Adab al-Mufrad because he did not put those strict conditions on his other books, as he put in Sahih Bukhari. He narrated all the ahadith in Sahih Bukhari after doing a great deal of research, but he did not do that in his other books, he was lenient in his other works. That's why he didn't care narrating weak ahadith in Adab al-Mufrad, as other scholars did.

If it would have been permissible according to Imam Bukhari to follow weak ahadith in Fadhaail, then he surely would have mentioned them in his Sahih Bukhari. Also, there are many incidences, where Imam Bukhari has weakened the ahadith of Fadhaail, which proves that Imam Bukhari did not take evidence from Weak ahadith even in Fadhaail.

Even if for the sake of argument, we agree that Imam Bukhari did believe in following Weak ahadith in Fadhaail, then still the aforementioned six conditions for a Da'eef hadith to be accepted will be followed, as said by the other group of scholars.




Fourth Objection:


The Brother again said:

 
Also one of the greatest mufasireen of this Ummah is Imam ibn Kathir rahimahullah. He compiled one of the greatest commentary of the Quran known as tafsir ibn Kathir in which only authentic sources are used. However Imam ibn Kathir also wrote other books, in which he used WEAK hadith. An example is the history book Al-Bidaya wa Nihaya. The Imam used weak hadith because its allowed to do so for history, adab and generally encouraging virtue


Answer:


The Brother has either said this, without any information of Al-Bidaya wal Nihaya, or he has said it based on his desire Because this is not what Imam Ibn Kathir has done in his Tafsir or History. All the ahadith that Imam Ibn Kathir has narrated in his Tafsir and History, are either authentic according to him, or he has mentioned their weakness after narrating them without taking any evidence from them.

If the Brother thinks that what He has said is true, then why couldn't he show any example from his history book, where he agreed that a certain Hadith is Weak and still took evidence from it?

I am sure, he won't find any such example in it. Inshallah. Because Imam Ibn Kathir never took evidence from Weak ahadith. For your information, Imam Ibn Kathir has written a full book on the principles of Hadith called, "Ikhtisaar Uloom al-Hadith", and in this huge book, he has mentioned several times that a Da'eef hadith is not permissible to act upon, but he didn't mention even a single time saying that a Da'eef hadith is acceptable in Fadhaail.

Imagine, a man writing a full book on Usul ul-Hadith, and doesn't mention the very important principle in it. Is it possible??



Fifth Objection:


Brother then, Quoted a sayinng of Imam Nawawi proving his stance:

 
The famous hadith scholar and jurist, Imam al-Nawawî writes in the introduction to his Forty Hadith: "Scholars agree that weak hadith which speak merely about the virtues of deeds can be cited."


Answer:


I agree, with my Brother that this saying is proven from Imam Nawawi. But I would also like to remind him that Imam Nawawi is among those first group of scholars who consider it permissible to act upon a Da'eef hadith in Fadhaail, but those scholars also put those six conditions which I have mentioned above in order for a Da'eef hadith to be accepted. so If you claim to follow Imam Nawawi, then you can't just follow any Da'eef hadith in Fadhaail, that hadith have to fulfil those conditions for it to be permissible. Please read the conditions again.



The more correct view on Da'eef ahadith is that, they are not permissible to act upon whether they are in Aqaaid, or Fadhaail.

Jamaal ud-Deen Qaasmi has narrated the first madhab on this issue, by saying that:

"Whether it is Ahkaam or Fadhaail, a Da'eef hadith will not be accepted, Ibn Atheer an-Naas has narrated it in Ayoon al-Athar from Imam Ibn Ma'een (the teacher of Imam Bukhari), and has attributed to Abu Bakr bin Al-Arabi in Fathul Mugheeth.

This is also the view of Imam Ibn Hazm, and Imam Ibn Taymiyyah.

so It is proven from the Majority of scholars and scholars that are ven greater than Imam Nawawi, to reject the Da'eef hadith in Fadhaail as well.